In a ruling, the US Supreme Court struck down Washington DC’s ban on handguns. The judgement is likely to lead to fewer restrictions on the ownership, sale, and possession of firearms.



FRONT PAGE
SiteSearch
About us
Directories


Mass shootings USA
US gun contol in tatters
American policing
US mayors fight against guns
Security cameras in US cities
Youth curfews in US cities
US prison closures - Cities
Vision for metro America
US urban inequality
US mayors silent on racial profiling
Obamas' urban policies
Maras street gangs
America jails its youth
America's children of prisoners
Urban crime 2007
Minorities in the US
Black American men
Low-cost clothing to curb inner city violence
US affordable housing crisis
Los Angeles migration
Poverty in US cities


City Mayors reports news from towns and cities around the world. Worldwide | Elections | North America | Latin America | Europe | Asia | Africa | Events |


Mayors from The Americas, Europe. Asia, Australia and Africa are competing for the annual World Mayor Award. More


City Mayors ranks the world’s largest as well as richest cities and urban areas. It also ranks the cities in individual countries, and provides a list of the capital cities of some 200 sovereign countries. More


City Mayors reports political events, analyses the issues and depicts the main players. More


City Mayors describes and explains the structures and workings of local government in Europe, The Americas, Asia, Australia and Africa. More


City Mayors profiles city leaders from around the world and questions them about their achievements, policies and aims. More


City Mayors deals with economic and investment issues affecting towns and cities. More


City Mayors reports on how business developments impact on cities and examines cooperation between cities and the private sector. More


City Mayors describes and explains financial issues affecting local government. More


City Mayors lists and features urban events, conferences and conventions aimed at urban decision makers and those with an interst in cities worldwide. More


City Mayors reports urban environmental developments and examines the challenges faced by cities worldwide. More


City Mayors reports on and discusses urban development issues in developed and developing countries. More


City Mayors reports on developments in urban society and behaviour and reviews relevant research. More


City Mayors deals with urban transport issues in developed and developing countries and features the world’s greatest metro systems. More


City Mayors examines education issues and policies affecting children and adults in urban areas. More


City Mayors investigates health issues affecting urban areas with an emphasis on health in cities in developing countries. More


City Mayors examines the importance of urban tourism to city economies. More


City Mayors examines the contributions history and culture make to urban society and environment. More


City Mayors describes the history, architecture and politics of the greatest city halls in the world. More


City Mayors invites readers to write short stories about people in cities around the world. More


City Mayors questions those who govern the world’s cities and talks to men and women who contribute to urban society and environment. More


City Mayors profiles national and international organisations representing cities as well as those dealing with urban issues. More


City Mayors reports on major national and international sporting events and their impact on cities. More


City Mayors lists cities and city organisations, profiles individual mayors and provides information on hundreds of urban events. More

Supreme Court rules against
US cities fighting gun violence

By Tony Favro, USA Editor

28 June 2008: A June 2008 US Supreme Court ruling on gun control appears to be a clear defeat for American cities struggling to control gun violence. The ruling struck down the city of Washington DC’s ban on handguns and will likely lead to fewer restrictions on the ownership, sale, and possession of firearms.

Update December 2012: US mayors fight against guns

The DC laws
In 1976, the US capital Washington DC passed laws banning handguns and requiring other firearms to be stored disassembled or with trigger locks. The laws had survived numerous legal challenges over the years. In March 2008, the conservative Bush Supreme Court heard the latest challenge. The plaintiff argued before the Supreme Court that he felt unsafe because he had to store his personal firearms outside the city. The plaintiff and his allies asked that the 32-year-old DC laws be struck down as violations of the Second Amendment of the US Constitution.

Collective versus individual rights
The Second Amendment states that “A well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” This sentence is at the center of gun control disputes in the US.

One interpretation of the phrase is that gun ownership is a collective right, connected to the formation of a government militia or military force. Gun control advocates and the city of Washington, DC support this view, as have most judges until now.

The opposing view holds that gun ownership is an individual right, and the state militia clause is essentially irrelevant. Last year, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, by a 2-1 vote, became the first appellate court to uphold this interpretation, paving the way for the US Supreme Court to hear the case.

The Supreme Court’s agreement with the individual rights interpretation means that firearms restrictions could be subjected to more rigorous scrutiny by judges protecting what is now considered a fundamental right guaranteed by the Constitution.

Mayors’ views
Washington, DC received support in its defense of gun control before the Supreme Court from the cities of Baltimore, Cleveland, Los Angeles, Milwaukee, New York City, Oakland, Philadelphia, Sacramento, San Francisco, Seattle and Trenton. These cities, joined by the US Conference of Mayors, filed an amicus brief, which argues, “Gun violence poses a serious threat to American cities. In roughly the last thirty years, the United States Department of Justice reports that there were over 340,000 homicides in large American cities. Over sixty per cent of the nation’s homicides during that period were committed using a gun… In addition to this terrible human toll, communities such as amici cities face massive economic costs and losses due to the fear and danger associated with gun violence.”

The brief continues that, “Firearms regulation is a critical part of cities’ efforts to protect the health and safety of their residents. Cities have adopted a wide range of measures – from bans on certain types of weapons and ammunition to eligibility and registration requirement – to reduce the threat of gun violence in their communities. The range of measures cities have adopted reflects the variety of challenges cities face and underscores the need for local flexibility in this area.”

There are few issues in recent years on which US urban mayors are more united and more vocal than gun control. In 2006, Mayor Thomas Menino of Boston and Mayor Michael Bloomberg of New York City formed Mayors Against Illegal Guns. The bipartisan coalition now includes more than 320 US mayors who work with their state and federal representatives to pass legislation designed to keep guns out of the hands of criminals. 

At least 38 states are currently considering gun safety laws ranging from strengthening ownership and registration requirements to making it easier to track guns, especially those used in crimes. With the Supreme Court’s ruling on the Washington, DC case, the status of all this proposed legislation is now in question.

Future outlook
The Supreme Court’s decision does not overturn all existing gun laws in the US. Certain guns laws, such as those prohibiting individuals convicted of serious crimes from owning guns, will still stand. What the ruling does essentially is to change the standard by which all gun laws in the US are evaluated.

Generally, gun laws have been allowed in the US so long as they are reasonable. Observers expect that the courts will now adopt a stricter measure of scrutiny, allowing gun laws only when they meet a compelling, and narrowly defined, state interest.

The federal government supports stricter scrutiny. Vice President Dick Cheney signed a legal brief demanding that the Supreme Court strike down the DC law immediately. A majority of Congress – 55 senators and 250 members of the House of Representatives – also signed a brief asking the court to overturn the DC gun ban. Many believe that the federal representatives were acquiescing to the will of the National Rifle Association (NRA), an organization that promotes the right to own firearms. The NRA has 4.3 million members and is widely considered to be the most effective lobbying organization in America.

Five states and several organizations including the American Bar Association and the American Academy of Pediatricians filed briefs in support of Washington, DC.

Litigation will likely continue for years about how the stricter standard will be defined and applied. And the debate over collective versus individual rights will likely never be resolved. The only certainty for America’s cities is that the uphill climb to use gun control laws to curb urban violence has become much steeper.

A memorial to teen-on-teen gun violence: an 18-year old motorist allegedly shot his 14-year old bicyclist victim in what Philadelphia police describe as a ‘road rage’ incident. This was the 220th homicide in Philadelphia in 2007. (Photo by D W Webber)


Also by Tony Favro
America prefers to punish rather than to provide care
An African-America boy born in the US in 2001 has a 1 in 3 chance of going to prison in his lifetime.  A Latino boy has a 1 in 6 chance. These statistics are from a recently released report America’s Cradle to Prison Pipeline by the Children’s Defense Fund, a nonprofit organization that encourages preventive investment in youth and families before problems occur.  The report blames America’s disproportionate investment in punishment rather than prevention for trapping many children in a trajectory that leads to marginalized lives and imprisonment.

Speaking of at-risk youth in the US, Marian Wright Edelman, founder and CEO of the Children’s Defense Fund, says, “We choose to punish and lock them up rather than take the necessary more cost-effective steps to prevent and intervene early to ensure… they reach successful adulthood.” More