Per capita emission of greenhouse gas in Beijing is half that of Sydney, according to a new report
FRONT PAGE
Site Search
About us | Quiénes somos |
A propos de nous | Über uns |
Code of Ethics
Mayor Monitor
Directories
Events
Debate
Greenhouse gas emissions
Urban ecological footprint
Urban energy saving (USA)
Green cities initiative
Green finance
Gas drilling in eastern US cities
Cities' green policies
Green mayors
US cities to go green
Mexico City's Green Plan
North America's greenest cities
Europe's greenest cities
Scottish Green energy
Cities and biodiversity
Mexico City garbage disposal
Sustainable communities
Liveable cities
Saving energy by using contrast
Great Lakes initiative
Issues facing megacities
Dubai & Shanghai development
Pros and cons of biofuels
Smart growth in US cities
Greenest US cities
Green schools
Most polluted US cities
Sustainable communities
under threat
City Mayors reports news from towns and cities around the world. Worldwide | Elections | North America | Latin America | Europe | Asia | Africa |
Mayors from The Americas, Europe. Asia, Australia and Africa compete for the World Mayor Award. More
City Mayors ranks the world’s largest, best as well as richest cities and urban areas. It also ranks the cities in individual countries, and provides a list of the capital cities of some 200 sovereign countries. More
City Mayors profiles city leaders from around the world. More
City Mayors describes the history, architecture and politics of the greatest city halls in the world. More
Use Mayor Monitor to rate the performance of mayors from across the world More
In your opinion: Praise Criticise. Write
City Mayors reports political events, analyses the issues and depicts the main players. More
City Mayors describes and explains the structures and workings of local government in Europe, The Americas, Asia, Australia and Africa. More
City Mayors deals with economic and investment issues affecting towns and cities. More
City Mayors describes and explains financial issues affecting local government. More
City Mayors reports urban environmental developments and examines the challenges faced by cities worldwide. More
City Mayors reports on and discusses urban development issues in developed and developing countries. More
City Mayors reports on developments in urban society and behaviour and reviews relevant research. More
City Mayors invites readers to write about the people in their cities. More
City Mayors examines city brands and marketing. More
City Mayors lists and features urban events, conferences and conventions aimed at urban decision makers and those with an interest in cities worldwide. More
City Mayors deals with urban transport issues in developed and developing countries and features the world’s greatest metro systems. More
City Mayors examines education issues and policies affecting children and adults in urban areas. More
City Mayors investigates health issues affecting urban areas with an emphasis on health in cities in developing countries. More
City Mayors reports on how business developments impact on cities and examines cooperation between cities and the private sector. More
City Mayors examines the contributions history and culture make to urban society and environment. More
City Mayors examines the importance of urban tourism to city economies. More
City Mayors questions those who govern the world’s cities and talks to men and women who contribute to urban society and environment. More
City Mayors profiles national and international organisations representing cities as well as those dealing with urban issues. More
City Mayors reports on major national and international sporting events and their impact on cities. More
City Mayors lists cities and city organisations, profiles individual mayors and provides information on hundreds of urban events. More
Greenhouse gases: Rich cities,
not big cities, are main culprits
A report by the International Institute for
Environment and Development
reviewed by Brian Baker*
17 February, 2011: It’s the wealthy cities - not big cities in general - that produce most greenhouse gases, according to a new study. David Satterthwaite, editor of the academic journal Environment and Urbanization, who is to publish the research in April, said: “It is the world’s wealthiest cities and their wealthiest inhabitants that cause unsustainable levels of greenhouse gas emissions, not cities in general.” He added: “Most cities in Africa, Asia and Latin America have low emissions per person. The challenge for them is to keep these emissions low even as their wealth grows.”The new study into greenhouse gas emissions found that major cities were not the worst culprits and that the developing world’s cities were often still performing better than those elsewhere despite fast industrial growth. The researchers urge policy makers and international institutions to take a broader look at climate change. They said: “Cities are major players in climate change mitigation but climate change will require city administrations to develop more robust partnerships with their constituencies in low and middle income countries.”
The study adds that cities have the potential to capitalise on the co-benefits of mitigation, adaptation and improved access to services. “Cities with excellent services are resilient.” The report draws on a comprehensive range of sources and data that helped the three authors identify and analyse emissions per person in 100 cities in 33 countries and to arrive at some innovative and surprising conclusions.
However, there was a note of caution regarding making extensive comparisons between individual cities in the list. Some of the data was not from peer-reviewed work and not all of it was recent. The authors suggest that more global debate is necessary on understanding fully the factors leading to emissions and in seeking agreement on how they should be measured and responsibility apportioned.
Crucially, the measurement of consumption and production in parallel was necessary to attempt effective analysis of the carbon footprints of individuals and of places. On an assessment that reflects both production and consumption and relates carbon emissions to lifestyles, many of the worst production polluters over the past ten years, notably the larger cities of China, become much less of the problem and wealthy cities with aspiring populations become more central to it.
One of the authors, Daniel Hoornweg, a World Bank climate change expert, observed: “Lifestyles and consumption patterns are key drivers of greenhouse gas emissions in far-off cities as in the example of Western consumer demand for Chinese goods. From the production perspective Shanghai has high emissions but from the consumption perspective its emissions are much lower.”
Of the 100 cities addressed, the highest greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions ((tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (tco2e)/capita)) were attributed to Rotterdam at 29.8. The highest attributed to one of the cities commonly cited as one of the world’s greats was Sydney at 20.3.
Port cities were affected by the production/consumption dynamic as measures of their pollution included fuel for the dirty diesel sea-going craft that transport goods in such large quantities to the affluent.
China’s cities record much higher emissions than those of India, though none of the India data is peer-reviewed or recent. While the large cities of China have much higher emissions than the nation overall, the writers point out that a lot of industrial production takes place within cities and that rural lifestyles are not dominated by private motorised transport.
In contrast with China, all the US cities are less polluting than the nation overall, reinforcing the view that the pattern of habitation, production and consumption in the US is generally more sustainable in the metropolitan areas. The report highlights the role of large volumes of private motorised travel in conjunction with low density development.
The biggest cities tend to have the best sustainable mobility systems and the highest population densities so it will be no surprise to those who keep in touch with climate change that these have lower emissions per person than those cities that are both wealthy and allow low density development.
Calgary’s GHG tCO2e capita is double that of Toronto and three times that of Vancouver. In 2005, New Yorker’s average emissions were less than half those of Denver inhabitants. San Francisco’s emissions are less than 50 per cent of that of any of the Texas cities included in the survey.
Another of the report’s authors, Lorraine Sugar, is Toronto-based. She says that residential emissions in a dense inner city neighbourhood there are 1.3 tonnes of Co2, equivalent per person, while in the same conurbation in an outer suburb it is 13 tonnes.
In Europe the city/nation matrix is more mixed but most of the big cities are less polluting than their national averages. Helsinki and Stockholm are both cited at 50 per cent, as are Barcelona and Madrid. Stuttgart, in contrast, is 50 per cent above the German average, though this may in part be because of the particular wind patterns affecting the Baden-Württemberg capital.
The writers concede that measuring the true responsibility of cities and city dwellers is very difficult, and comparing them even more so.
Per capital CHG emissions
for selected countries and cities
|
Country/city
|
GHG emission (tCO2e/capita)
|
| Argentina |
7.64
|
| Buenos Aires |
3.83
|
| Australia |
25.75
|
| Sydney |
20.3
|
| Belgium |
12.36
|
| Brussels |
7.5
|
| Brazil |
4.16
|
| Rio de Janeiro |
2.1
|
| São Paulo |
1.4
|
| Canada |
22.65
|
| Calgary |
17.7
|
| Toronto (City of Toronto) |
9.5
|
| Toronto (Metropolitan Area) |
11.6
|
| Vancouver |
4.9
|
| China |
3.40
|
| Beijing |
10.1
|
| Shanghai |
11.7
|
| France |
8.68
|
| Paris |
5.2
|
| Germany |
11.62
|
| Frankfurt |
13.7
|
| Hamburg |
9.7
|
| Stuttgart |
16.0
|
| Greece |
11.78
|
| Athens |
10.4
|
| Italy |
9.31
|
| Bologna (Province) |
11.1
|
| Naples (Province) |
4.0
|
| Turin |
9.7
|
| Japan |
10.76
|
| Tokyo |
4.89
|
| Mexico |
5.53
|
| Mexico City |
4.25
|
| Netherlands |
12.67
|
| Rotterdam |
29.8
|
| Spain |
9.86
|
| Barcelona |
4.2
|
| Madrid |
6.9
|
| Sweden |
7.15
|
| Stockholm |
3.6
|
| Switzerland |
6.79
|
| Geneva |
7.8
|
| UK |
10.50
|
| London |
9.6
|
| Glasgow |
8.8
|
| USA |
23.59
|
| Austin |
15.57
|
| Baltimore |
14.4
|
| Boston |
13.3
|
| Chicago |
12.0
|
| Dallas |
15.2
|
| Denver |
21.5
|
| Houston |
14.1
|
| Philadelphia |
11.1
|
| Juneau |
14.37
|
| Los Angeles |
13.0
|
| Menlo Park |
16.37
|
| Miami |
11.9
|
| Minneapolis |
18.34
|
| New York City |
10.5
|
| Portland, OR |
12.41
|
| San Diego |
11.4
|
| San Francisco |
10.1
|
| Seattle |
13.68
|
| Washington DC |
19.70
|
*Environment and Urbanization is published by Sage Publications and the International Institute of Environment and Development. Cities and Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Moving Forward. 2011. Environment and Urbanization Vol 23 (2). www.iied.org Authors D. Hoornweg, L. Sugar, C. L. Trejos Gomez.
Comment on this article
Read comments
